Monday, October 23, 2017

Fighting to protect the Flathead: FBC funding in doubt due to proposed budget cuts

POLSON — An impending state budget cut has forced the Flathead Basin Commission to consider alternative funding mechanisms, including a possible alliance with Lake and Flathead counties and the Confederated Salish and Kootenai Tribes.
The FBC is a state entity that was created in 1983 to protect the Flathead Basin — a large geographic area encompassing Flathead and Lake counties and a portion of Missoula County in the Seeley Lake area — from pollution resulting from coal mining and other natural resource extraction in British Columbia. It succeeded in that effort through a memorandum of understanding with British Columbia and a ruling by the International Joint Commission that a Canadian coal mine would harm fisheries in Montana. 
Originally under the direction of the governor’s office, the FBC was later administratively attached to the Department of Natural Resources and Conservation, FBC Executive Director Caryn Miske said. 
DNRC spokesman John Grassy said the state agency has proposed a cut of some $140,000 in the FBC’s budget for the current and next fiscal years. Although Grassy said the state would still honor legal contracts, the cut would mean that Miske would be out of a job unless other funds could be procured. 
Miske said the proposed cut represents the organization’s entire budget - her salary of $85,000 and the remaining $55,000 used for operating expenses. 
Gov. Steve Bullock has asked most state agencies to propose 10-percent budget cuts in response to declining revenue, at least part of which is related to firefighting efforts this summer. The state’s budget shortfall is estimated at $227 million.
DNRC Director John Tubbs said his state agency proposed $2.96 million in cuts over the two-year cycle. When asked to explain the proposed cut to the FBC, Tubbs noted that the state is funding $6.5 million for anti-aquatic invasive species efforts over the biennium. That funding represents a 600-percent increase over the previous budget that was just under $1 million, he said. As a result of legislation that was passed earlier this year, he said the state is funding 150 seasonal staff and 34-plus inspection or decontamination stations.
“Are we protecting the Flathead? Yes,” Tubbs said.
Miske met with Lake County Commissioners Gale Decker, Bill Barron and Dave Stipe on Oct. 3. During the hour-long back and forth session, commissioners were resolute in their willingness to support FBC.
Decker later said that cutting the FBC’s funding completely is a mistake, but added that they could deal with a 10-percent cut. He said the FBC has been ahead of the curve in fighting aquatic invasive species. FBC has funded a station on the south end of Kalispell at Jesco Marine and Power Sports and has helped the Blackfeet Tribe and CSKT with three stations on the Blackfeet Reservation and one in Pablo.
Should Flathead Lake become fouled with mussels, the Flathead Lake Biological Station at Yellow Bay has estimated that it would reduce the property values around the lake by 20-30 percent, Decker said. 
The recently passed HB 622 lets the FBC establish a pilot program for mussel control in the Flathead Lake region but the rules for such a program are to be approved by DNRC, Miske said. She doubts however, DNRC will approve the rules by a March 1 deadline, which is when anti-AIS efforts normally begin in the state with inspection stations and public education efforts. Plans were to require all boats, including local, in-state and out-of-state, to be inspected prior to launch on Flathead Lake next year. 
Miske, an attorney by trade, also performs a number of other duties for FBC, including fundraising. She said the FBC raised some $600,000 for the Blackfeet stations over the past two years through multiple grants. 
A new governmental alliance?
Miske said Lake and Flathead counties could, along with CSKT, adopt anti-AIS ordinances as part of a joint venture. Lake County Deputy Civil Attorney Wally Congdon said the county could add an anti-AIS ordinance under its nuisance statute that also includes noxious weeds, for example. “We can regulate it as a nuisance today,” he said.  
“If we could get an ordinance that worked here, we could get it adopted by the state,” Commissioner Barron said.
Miske said if such an alliance were created, the entity “would not have to deal with the state” for funding, although they would have to raise new funds or re-allocate some. The governor can cut the organization’s budget, but since the Legislature created the FBC it would not have to reorganize, she said. 
“I think we gotta go out on a limb a little bit, but I think we can get it done,” Commissioner Decker said of the alternative plan should the governor implement DNRC’s proposal to defund the FBC. 
Miske expressed her disappointment about the state’s anti-AIS efforts thus far.
“If we lose Flathead, we’ve lost the golden goose,” she said.
During their meeting, Lake County Commissioners and Miske concluded that politics played a role in the decision to cut the FBC’s budget. Miske noted that ultimately it’s up to the governor to make the decision. Gov. Bullock has talked about calling a special session of the state Legislature to find a better path forward. 
Decontamination stations?
According to Miske, boats were routinely leaving the Tiber and Canyon Ferry reservoirs this year without being decontaminated even though the boat owners had paperwork saying they were.
“We hoped containment at Tiber and Canyon would be real,” she said, but added that what has been established there is “weak.” Mussel larvae were found last year at Tiber Reservoir and were suspected at Canyon Ferry and in the Missouri River.
Miske said two inspection/decontamination stations were set up at both Tiber and Canyon Ferry earlier this year. There are multiple launch sites at those lakes and boaters are directed to an inspection station when leaving. Some stop and some don’t, she said, adding that no one forces them to stop. In addition, she said that Montana Fish, Wildlife and Parks changed the definition of decontamination this year. This resulted in boats being inspected and deemed decontaminated because they were “clean, drained and dry” but not necessarily decontaminated, she said.
Jay Monroe, the AIS program coordinator for the Blackfeet Tribe, confirmed Miske’s comments. He said several boats came from a walleye tournament on Tiber Reservoir in May. These boats had a purple hitch seal that meant they passed inspection. Their paperwork, an “AIS mussel-free risk assessment form,” said they had been decontaminated and that a hot wash wasn’t necessary. However, Monroe noted that a full decontamination consists of washing the interior of the boat with a water temperature of at least 120 degrees and the exterior at 140 degrees. But since these boats had been deemed clean by a state agency (Fish, Wildlife and Parks), Monroe said there wasn’t a whole lot that his inspectors could do. 
He also said that two mussel-fouled boats were stopped earlier this year at Blackfeet stations located on U.S. 2 west of Cut Bank, on Highway 89 at Birch Creek and U.S. 2 west of Browning. Both boats stopped came from the Midwest. In one case a Columbia Falls-area man purchased a boat that had been on Lake Michigan and intended to sell it in Montana. The other boat was also from the Midwest and its owner intended to launch on Flathead Lake. Both were given a white failed inspection hitch seal and directed to the Whitefish Lake Institute for “hot-wash” decontamination. The Whitefish Lake Institute and Fish, Wildlife and Parks were notified about each case, he said.
The fine for launching with a white hitch seal is $10,000, Monroe said.
Barron said some boaters have bypassed open inspection stations in Lake County without being cited. “After you catch him, what do you do? Nothing,” he said. “It should’ve been a felony.”
He said law enforcement has stopped and escorted some violators back to an inspection station. 
“You only have to write a handful of tickets and word gets out,” Miske said. Violators can be cited and fined $85 for not stopping at an inspection station.
Inspectors across the state found nine boats with mussels this year, including the two in Browning and one in Kalispell, according to CSKT’s aquatic invasive species coordinator Erik Hanson. Those findings point toward the need for continued anti-AIS efforts. Regardless of how budget cuts are handled, local entities will continue to be involved in the battle.

Tuesday, September 19, 2017

Anti-AIS bill passes, waiting for governor’s signature

A Senate bill that would fund $13.9 million over two years to fight aquatic invasive species has been approved by the Legislature and waits for the governor’s signature.
All indications are that Gov. Steve Bullock will sign the bill, which is an attempt to prevent mussels from expanding from eastern Montana after mussel larvae were found in at least one lake last year.
SB 363 survived the amendment process and was approved by the Senate 39- 10 following a 95-5 vote in the House.
State Sen. Chas Vincent, R-Libby, spearheaded the funding effort, which will add a fee to users of hydroelectric power and fishing licenses.
The bill would require outof- staters to pay $15 more a year for a fishing license, while in-state residents would pay an extra $2. Vendors of fishing licenses will be able to collect a 50-cent fee for printing prevention passes that go with the fishing license fees.
Users of Flathead Electric would pay an additional 25 cents a month for every 1,000 kilowatt hours using a “pretty complicated formula,” Vincent said. The hydroelectric fees will be regulated by the state Public Service Commission.
Requirements that in-state and out-of-state residents pay $25 and $50, respectively, for boat decals and irrigators $25 a year were removed from the bill, along with an amendment to require out-of-state residents pay $25 a year to register their bicycles in the state and a fee on plastic non-recyclable bottle caps.
The bill would “sunset” in two years so the Legislature can revisit the issue.
“I’m glad we’re coming back in two years,” Vincent said, calling the bill “good news” and a “stop-gap measure.”
As a veteran legislator, Vincent said he felt compelled to take the bull by the horns and move forward with the legislation. “
It was different for me to carry a bill creating fees,” he said. “Somebody needed to step up and get it done.”
The state’s anti-AIS plan calls for adding 17 inspection stations to the 17 used last year. In addition, four decontamination stations would be set up for watercraft at Canyon Ferry and Tiber reservoirs on the east side of the state.
The plan would require out-of-state watercraft to be inspected prior to launch in Montana, along with those crossing from east to west inside the state.
The Confederated Salish and Kootenai Tribes are requiring all watercraft users to get inspected at least once prior to entering Flathead Lake or the Lower Flathead River. On all other water bodies on the Flathead Indian Reservation, one can only use hand-propelled, non-trailered watercraft such as kayaks, canoes, rafts and paddleboards.

Anti-AIS bill passes Senate, heads to House; Bill would fund $11M effort to fight mussels

State Sen. Chas Vincent, R-Libby, is doing his best to prevent mussels from infesting the Columbia River Basin.
Vincent filed a bill, SB 363, at the “11th hour” in order to fund mussel prevention efforts in the state.
Montana Fish, Wildlife and Parks earlier this year requested $10.2 million in funding for the next two years for their plan to prevent mussels from spreading after larvae were found in one or two eastern Montana lakes last year.
Vincent’s bill aims to fund $11 million for the mussel- prevention program. The bill was approved by the Senate 32-18 on March 31 and now goes to the House.
As it currently stands, the bill would require out-ofstaters to pay $15 more a year for a fishing license, while in-state residents would pay an extra $2.
The bill would also require users of hydroelectricity to pay a user fee.
Requirements that in-state and out-of-state residents pay $25 and $50, respectively, for boat decals and irrigators $25 a year, were removed from the bill on March 30. Vincent said via email that the “decals were going to be an administrative nightmare for FWP, so we worked with them to remedy this problem” by increasing fishing license fees.
An amendment requested by Sen. President Scott Sales, R-Bozeman, was approved 26-24 to require out-of-state residents pay $25 a year to register their bicycles in the state.
The bill would “sunset” in two years so the Legislature can revisit the issue.
“I’ve never carried a fee-increase bill,” said Vincent, noting he’s been in the Legislature since 2007. But he believes such funding would be for something that he called “the proper role of government.”
If the state doesn’t fight mussels now, it could end up costing $50 million during the next legislative session in two years, he said.
“This is a fiscally conservative response to do this now,” he said.
He noted the work on fighting mussels began late last year when Gov. Steve Bullock created an emergency task force that began working on a plan to fight aquatic invasive species.
“The inter-agency cooperation has been incredible,” Vincent said. “I’m proud to be helping them implement what they put together.”
Vincent said he would have preferred to use the state’s General Fund to fight mussels, but that’s not feasible since it’s a tight budget year.
“Everyone will feel the pain with a mussel infestation and will see an increase in utility rates,” he said.
The cost to the affected electric cooperatives would be $611,000 per year, which on a per member basis would be $3.43 a year for a customer who uses 1,000 kilowatts a month. “It would be a bit lower for the regulated utilities because they have a larger consumer base,” he said.
Hydroelectric power users “stand to lose the most from zebra mussels spreading,” he said, rationalizing that they should pay to help prevent an infestation.
The mussel-infestation plan calls for adding 17 inspection stations to the 17 used last year. In addition, four decontamination stations would be set up for watercraft at Canyon Ferry and Tiber reservoirs on the east side of the state.
The plan would require out-of-state watercraft to be inspected prior to launch in Montana, along with those crossing from east to west inside the state. The plan has been peer-reviewed by other states already affected by mussels and was given five stars, Vincent said.
An amendment was approved on March 30 that would put any federal anti- mussel funding the state receives into an AIS trust fund created two years ago by a bill sponsored by Rep. Mark Noland, R-Bigfork. The amendment would raise the cap on the trust fund to $100 million from $10 million. The trust fund has not been funded to date. The amendment requires approval of three-quarters of the Legislature to use any principal in the fund.
Vincent’s bill is the funding side of the anti-AIS legislation. Rep. Mike Cuffe, R-Eureka, is sponsoring a bill dealing with the policy side, Vincent said.


He’s very confident that the bill, which he called “a good bipartisan educational process,” will pass the House and be signed into law by the governor.

FLIC film features pilgrimage across Spain

POLSON – The Camino de Santiago is the way of pilgrims.
That’s the message of Travel Light, a movie shown Saturday at the Flathead Lake International Cinemafest. The film earned the 2017 FLIC People's Choice award.
Lindsay Thompson produced the documentary based on a 37-day, 500-mile hike that she took from St. Jean- Pied-de-Port in southwest France through Santiago de Compostela, Spain, onto Finisterra along the Atlantic Ocean. She hiked with three friends.
Their trek started in mountains, went through some flat land and then finished in more mountains. The Camino de Santiago, or Way of James, ends in Santiago de Compostela, where legend has it that the remains of the Biblical Apostle James were buried and a cathedral built in his honor.
Thompson and her friends suffered from various aches and pains along the way, and one had to cut short her hike, but the group got to meet a number of interesting pilgrims too. The film includes several interviews with pilgrims the group met along the way, and one interview with an alchemist.
Each night they stayed in an “albergues,” or hostel, and drank wines from the region. Thompson said the trails were first built by Celts and then added onto by Romans. Pilgrims, or peregrinos, she said, tend to find answers or direction for their lives on the camino.
After reaching Santiago de Compostela, the group enjoyed what one described as “Catholic Disneyland.” Alas, a much-anticipated party on the Day of St. James is canceled in the wake of a train crash.
The group ended their hike at Finisterra at a point overlooking the Atlantic Ocean.
Thompson said she heard about the trail in her high school Spanish class and had never backpacked more than two days before embarking on the camino.
She and two friends she met on the trail would like to hike it again.
Next time they may skip the trail’s flat mid-section or hike when it’s cooler, as it can get up to 110 degrees or so in the summer months.
The film earned an honorable mention for best picture/documentary short among more than 60 films shown throughout the weekend at Showboat Cinemas.
A full list of award winners is available on the FLIC Facebook page.

Local couple details trip to Mongolia, land of Eternal Blue Sky

They weren’t just “horsing around,” they also got to experience a new culture.
Columbia Falls residents Greg and Deb Schatz presented details of their trip to Mongolia on Friday at KwaTaq- Nuk Resort as part of the Montana Back Country Horsemen convention.
Greg said Mongolia was the only foreign country the couple wanted to visit. That’s because of their love of horses.
“The horse packing in Montana came from Mongolia,” he said, explaining that it came through the Spaniards who traveled up from Mexico.
The Schatzs visited the Darhad Valley in the Mongolian state of Khuvsgol Aimig for three weeks last summer.
It was the only the third time the couple had flown on an airplane since they married in 1988 and moved to the Flathead in 1989. They flew from Kalispell to Seattle on Alaska Airlines and then on Korean Air to Seoul and Ulaanbaater, the capital of Mongolia, which became a democracy in 1990.
Greg feels like he has a connection with the herders in the Darhad Valley. The steppes there are similar to those not far away in Russia where his great-grandparents on both sides of his family came from, he said.
The deep-fat fried doughnuts the Mongolian herders eat with just about every meal also remind him of what his ancestors ate, he said.
The Schatzs were part of 30 people who took the trip to ride horses alongside the herders. The trip was sponsored by the non-profit Bioregions International of Bozeman. Others who went were six Native American students from Montana State University, a medical team of five and a soils team of four, among others.
The Schatzs explained to the herders how they take different kinds of outfitter trips with members of the public into the Montana backcountry, including the “Leave No Trace” theme.
The culture of the Mongolian herders is such that they have “zero materialistic values,” Greg said. They live in little cabins, and while they are herding away from home they will sleep on the permafrost or in a 30-foot-diameter ger or yurt.
Deb said her most memorable part of the trip was “how they respect the land and how everything is sacred.” Typical herder religions range from shamanism to Buddhism to what Greg calls “naturalist.” which includes a respect for “Mother Earth” and “Father Sky.”
The herders do not dig the soil or cut the grass out of respect for the earth, so no gardens are grown. Ovoos, which consist of piles of stones or tree branches, are built on hills or mountains. Horse skulls and other objects such as khadag, or blue scarves, which represent the Eternal Blue Sky, are hung from them. Such offerings are made when one comes across an ovoo and circles it three times clockwise.
The herders will often tie or hobble their horses to their own legs or to another horse to prevent them from wandering off during stops if no post is nearby.
The typical horse lives to age 20 and is then “put down” and eaten by the herders. This is a form of respect, Greg said.
The herders raise horses, cows, Cashmere goats, sheep and yaks. The yaks are raised for their meat and milk, which is used to make cheese and yogurt, while sheep are raised for meat and fur. Reindeer live to the north of where the Schatzs visited, although they saw two on their trip.
Cottonwood trees grow near the riverbanks in the land of Genghis Khan with Siberian larch in the foothills and spruce and fir in the mountains, which Greg described as similar to Montana.
He noted that some 8.3 million acres have been set aside in Khuvsgol Aimig for state and national parks.
The Schatzs plan to return to Mongolia in the summer of 2018.

Cherry powdery mildew discussed at annual meeting

YELLOW BAY — Local cherry growers heard about cherry powdery mildew on Saturday.
Claudia Probst, a research associate at Washington State University- Prosser, spoke about the fungus before the Flathead Lake Cherry Growers, Inc.
Probst said the mildew is unique to the Pacific Northwest, and mildew that affects other plants is not the same as the kind that affects cherries.
Cherry powdery mildew is quite a problem in Washington but apparently not as prevalent in Montana.
The mildew affects the leaves of the cherry tree before appearing on the fruit just before harvest.
“As soon as you have a leaf infection you have to worry about it,” Probst said, adding that the mildew doesn’t appear on the leaves of the Sweetheart variety but can still affect the fruit.
Pruning a tree helps prevent the mildew because a well-pruned tree has a lot less disease.
“You can cover a well-pruned tree easier with fungicide,” she said.
Probst recommends rotating the types of fungicides one uses on trees. If spraying before and after a harvest is cost prohibitive, she recommends using it before.
Another effective remedy is sulfur, which kills fungus spores. One has to apply sulfur frequently, however, and use personal protective equipment. She cautions not to use sulfur once temperatures reach 80 degrees because it could damage the fruit.
Organic orchards can use stylet oil pre-harvest, she said.
Cherries that are harvested prior to Bing cherries, which she called “escapees,” typically do not contract the mildew. She added that the Chillan variety is not susceptible, and a man in the audience added that the Centennial variety does not contract the mildew either.
Cherries that have mildew can be put into brine with sulfur dioxide and made into Maraschino cherries, she said, adding this has been done in The Dalles, Oregon.
A person can eat cherries with mildew, she said, noting that she has.
“It’s a very neat little fungus … but you can’t export it,” Probst said.
She speculates that powdery mildew came to Montana from trees brought in from Washington. Those who would like more information on Probst’s research can search for “WSU Cherry Powdery Mildew Information Network” on Facebook.

Public Law 280 exit revision passes Legislature: Would speed up the process if tribes choose to withdraw

POLSON — A bill that would speed up the process if the Confederated Salish and Kootenai Tribes request to withdraw from Public Law 280 has passed both houses of the state Legislature. 
SB 310 passed the Senate 35-15 and the House 53-47. It now heads to Gov. Steve Bullock for a signature or veto. 
The bill doesn’t provide CSKT with any more rights, according to state Rep. Greg Hertz, R-Polson. If the tribes petition the governor to request removal from the law enforcement agreement, Bullock has six months to issue a proclamation releasing them from the agreement, Hertz said, noting the federal Department of the Interior also has to agree. 
Hertz said he prepared an amendment to the bill that would have offered the county the same rights as the tribes, but found out that it didn’t pass legal muster because the county technically isn’t a party to Public Law 280, an agreement between the state, federal and tribal governments. 
“The county is not an authorizer of anything with this agreement,” he said. 
Lake County commissioners passed a resolution to withdraw participation in the law in January. The resolution was an attempt to get funding from the state, federal or tribal governments due to a tight financial situation. 
The county has been prosecuting felony cases of tribal members since the 1960s. However, the county has seen declining revenues over the years due to the tribes putting land in trust, thus removing it from the tax rolls. 
According to county commissioner Bill Barron, the county loses approximately $3.5 million a year in property taxes due to land being put into trust by the CSKT or tribal members over the past 20 years or so. It’s become more of a problem over the past 10 years, according to Deputy County Attorney Wally Congdon. 
“Our mill would be twice what it is now if it weren’t for the trust,” Barron said last week. “We’re not blaming the tribe. It’s the way Congress set it up.” 
Barron said Lake County is working with the other 18 tribal counties in Montana on legislation to remedy the situation. A bill that would provide state reimbursement of property taxes for certain exempt tribal property, HB 615, was introduced by Rep. Greg Hertz, R-Polson, but tabled in the House Taxation Committee on March 29. 
Barron said an interim committee will study the issue and a bill may be brought forward in 2019. 
In addition, CSKT took over control of the Selis, Ksanka Qlispe (formerly Kerr) Dam in September 2015. This has cost the county some $800,000 a year, according to County Attorney Steve Eschenbacher. In the meantime the number of felony cases keeps rising. There were 182 in 2012 and nearly 500 last year. Earlier this year, Eschenbacher said 83 percent of felony cases in the county involve tribal members. 
County Commissioner Gale Decker was not happy with SB 310, having wanted the county to have the same rights as the tribes. The bill, sponsored by Sen. Lea Whitford, D-Cut Bank, “is a way for the tribe and the state to take an action that has a profound effect on Lake County, and the county government has no voice in the decision,” he said. 
“We may have to take money from other places to pay these continuing costs,” Decker said, noting the county is just starting to prepare a budget for the next fiscal year.  
Commissioner Dave Stipe said he wasn’t completely opposed to SB 310. “I think we’re going to work our way out of it,” he said. However he added that he doesn’t have the answers. He added that law enforcement is an obligation of the federal government that it should be paying for. (On other Indian reservations in the state, the Federal Bureau of Investigation and federal courts handle tribal felony cases.) 
Stipe said the way that Public Law 280 has worked up until now is that the tribes could petition to be removed and the Legislature could approve it, a process that could take two years. 
According to a CSKT press release dated April 24, the Tribal Council has decided to study the issue for now, but is pleased the bill passed the Legislature. 
“The Tribal Council is committed to carefully and deliberately evaluating potential arrangements to reduce the significant burden on our budget and our neighboring local governments,” the release states. “The Council is committed to consulting and working closely with state and local officials throughout the process.”